Efficient Copyright Infringement



Journal Title

Journal ISSN

Volume Title


Iowa Law Review


Copyright infringement is said to be socially costly because it robs owners of due recompense and depresses incentives for creative production. This Article contends that in order to achieve copyright’s goal of maximizing cultural production, this dominant story of infringement’s costs requires alongside it a counter-story identifying the rare but important instances where copyright infringement enhances social welfare. Part I explains the need for an account of the novel notion of efficient copyright infringement. Other types of unlawful conduct may also be beneficial, but copyright in particular warrants exploration of efficient infringement because maximizing creative production requires some level of unauthorized use, and because copyright’s political economy tilts in favor of expanding owners’ rights. Part II explores efficient copyright infringement’s domain, showing that unauthorized use of protected works of authorship will be prosocial where traditional private ordering is unavailable (or strongly undesirable) to facilitate a given use, and where that use is welfare-enhancing. Part III outlines broadly how a law of efficient copyright infringement might look. It first explains how the Copyright Act has failed to fully account for beneficial unauthorized use. It then considers a variety of ways that copyright damages could be structured to better accommodate efficient infringement. The Article concludes by situating this argument in the context of a growing literature that explores the surprising and underappreciated upside of unauthorized use of copyrighted works of authorship.



Arts and EntertainmentEconomics, Intellectual Property Law, Law and Economics, Law and Society, Property-Personal and Real, Public Law and Legal Theory


Copyright 2013 Iowa Law Review. Recommended citation: Fagundes, Dave. "Efficient Copyright Infringement." Iowa Law Review 98 (2013). DOI: 10.2139/ssrn.2132918 URL: https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2132918 Reproduced in accordance with licensing terms and with the author’s permission.